Cucina Fresca Italian American Specialty Market

Usually I’m not impressed when I order out Italian food but this place completely blew me away. They told me everything is home-made and let me tell you they weren’t lying! I usually don’t take the time to leave reviews but this place really left their mark on me. Absolutely phenomenal! I got the broccoli cavetelli, lasagna, and a pistachio/cake desert. My dad got two subs, eggplant parm, manicotti, and some stuffed cabbage thing. Everything was a 10/10! I 100% recommend for anyone to check this place out before the word gets around town and the lines are wrapped around the door bc it’s really that good!

Grabbed a chicken Parm sandwich for my husband and he couldn't get over how great it was! The bread was fresh and crispy the sauce wasn't acidic and the chicken was perfect! I will definitely come back and tell friends!

Absolutely delicious sandwiches, pastries, and more. I got a few different sandwiches and really liked them all. You could tell the ingredients were fresh and made with care. The pastries were the best I’ve ever had. This will for sure be my new go to spot and I’m so happy Cucina Fresca chose Bayville as their home.

If I could give 100 stars I would. Incredible sandwiches, pastries and great customer service. My father said it's the best sandwich he's had in 20 years, my fiance said it's the best chicken parm sandwich he's ever had in his life. We all thoroughly enjoyed Cucina Fresca! Literally hot fresh bread right from the oven, all homemade and delicious. Even during their opening, they knocked it out of the park. I would go out of my way to eat here again. 👏🏼

There is nothing like this place anywhere near here. Like being on Arthur Avenue in the Bronx! Highest quality meats and cheeses. Bread baked daily (multiple times!) Great selection of imported Italian pantry staples. And finally, I cannot begin to describe the bakery case - you've got to see it to believe it, amazing variety! And today was only their "soft" opening. I can't wait to see their prepared food selections. Staff also very friendly and helpful. Welcome to Bayville, Cucina Fresca! And, no, I am not related to the owners!